Reflections of an Artist
Plato's Rule

Faded Door 11x14 Oil
Plato was a Greek philosopher, writer, poet, genius. Yes, I knew that stuff about him but I never knew that Plato's philosophy extended to art but apparently it did; Plato's Rule. When asked by a student, "What makes a great composition in art?" Plato's response was, "Find and represent the variety within the unity".
How amazing is that statement? These two things, variety and unity seem to be contradictory principles but Plato's statement perfectly describes the crazy balancing act that every artist fights to master. It encompasses color, shape, value, composition, in fact everything that an artist must consider is balanced between these two principles. We know that variety and unity are both principles of art and we understand that both are essential in our artwork, but how we combine them together is the challenge. The answer is we must push our work to create variety but keep the variety confined to being unified. Tricky stuff.
Variety is the use of different elements in the artwork. Variety creates excitement. Art that has too much variety is "busy" and confused. Too much unity is boring. The artist's job is to find that perfect balance between the two.
Here are two paintings that illustrate this principle.

Edgar Degas The Millinery Shop
In Degas painting we can see the masterful combination of unity and variety.
- The repeated circle of hats unite the image while the diagonal of the table cuts across the shapes.
- The painting is mostly warm colors with splashes of blues and green
- The value is mostly dark with important highlights that lead us in a circle around the painting.

Jasper Johns
Abstract art needs this balance too.
- The triangle is repeated over and over in this painting, the composition is a triangle, the blue areas form a trianlge as do the red shape across the bottom. But they are varied and broken up with variety.
- The blue outline is the same throughout the painting, even on the wood panel in the background but the lines are jagged, unique and unpredictable.
- There are three areas of cool colors (the blue) and three areas of warm colors, yellow, red and orange/red with warm colors dominant.
The simplest statement unleashes a torrent of possibilities that we, the artist, are dedicated to solving. Have fun finding your balance.
4 Responses to Plato's Rule
Leave a Comment