Reflections of an Artist

Become Your Own Best Critic by Setting a Higher Standard

      I paint plein air often. It is a French term which translates as 'in the air' but the reality is not as glamorous. I carry all my gear for painting oils outside to a remote location and, in theory, create a masterpiece. But yesterday didn't go as planned. I ventured out to paint with a plein air group which meets once a month. The weather was cool but beautiful and I set my easel up in a lovely clearing at the edge of a pool of water. From the start I struggled, but finally at around lunch, I produced a painting which looked something like the scene I was painting. I had fun painting; it wasn't bad but this morning I wiped it down.

      Early in my career I rarely wiped away any of my efforts, but in recent years I have become more and more critical of my work and willing to abandon paintings that are not working. I get a perverse pleasure in destroying a painting which I consider not good enough. My joy has to do with the knowledge that I am better than the failed attempt I just destroyed. I know that tomorrow I will paint something I like.

      Setting a higher standard for my work has a number of effects. It has helped to improve my painting, I have a sense of satisfaction with the work I produce and I don't have stacks and stacks of bad paintings to store(not possible given the size of my studio). So what is the down side? There aren't any.

      I am not suggesting that you destroy every painting you think needs some tweaking, I am talking about the ones which despite your best efforts are never quite right. It is better to move on to something new than waste hours trying to make something work that never will. The trick is in recognizing the difference.


      But how does an artist decide if a painting is a keeper or one that should be destroyed? I think the key is to view your painting from a detached perspective. Compare your latest attempt to paintings you love. How do you feel when you look at them and then how do you feel about the painting you just did. If I start to list the things I need to change then I realize this is a candidate for the wipe-down.  How many changes are on my list will decide if it is a keeper or doomed.

  • The first and most important thing I look at is the composition. If I am happy with the composition there is a good chance the painting can be saved, if not it's adios; no exceptions.
  • Next, I consider the values and colors. How strong are the values and do I like the way the colors are interacting. Again, if I need to redo too much of the painting to be satisfied, I figure wiping it down is easier than reworking the painting. 
  • Is the painting unique in some way? Is it painted in a location I have never been before or one I may never come back to again. Is there something unusual about that specific time? A unique storm cloud, a once in a lifetime event or is it just another painting of a nice tree.

      The first time I ever wiped down one of my paintings was painful. I had spent hours trying, without success, to make it work. Every time after that I felt more and more empowered. I forced myself to understand the difference between what works and what doesn't and to act on that knowledge. It is a very important step to take. Being your own critic takes practise but it will accelerate the improvement of your work and who deserves that more than you?

Related Posts


Comments

4 Responses to Become Your Own Best Critic by Setting a Higher Standard

Wow, Sharon... first, I'm surprised you wiped it down... I thought it was nice......
but...
WHAT a powerful post! I think I should copy it and try to learn from it again and again. I have yet to learn the lesson you talked about here.

Thanks Marian. I am striving for satisfaction in my work and for me that means not settling for less than I know I am capable. I don't want to produce just for more product.

I have done the "wipe-down", Sharon, and there's something powerful in doing that too! And sometimes I set something aside, and ages later that tweak, if you will, comes to me and the art comes alive again.

Hi Bonnie
I was originally a fashion designer so I am drawn to textile and fiber art. Your work is wonderful and what a fun blog. Thanks for commenting on mine. I thought this topic would hit a nerve.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post