Reflections of an Artist
California Art Club Critique Session: The Making of Great Art
Criticism can be a good thing if it is coming from someone you respect,
someone who has achieved a level of expertise. That is the concept
behind the California Art Club Annual Critique Session: The Making of
Great Art, that took place on June 29 at the Autry Museum. Associate
members were encouraged to submit two works which were to be discussed by a
panel of accomplished artists. Joseph Mendez, Bela Bacsi, Tony Pro and
Amy Sidrane were the artists who gave their insight about the submitted
work.
I didn't submit any pieces but I knew I would still learn from the panels comments. Here are a few of their suggestions regarding value, composition, and texture.
Value: 1) Make sure your light source is constant so the highlights and shadows confirm the light direction. 2) Try squinting. This will simplify what you are looking at and reduce it to very easily seen shapes of light and dark. 3) Reflective light is a change in temperature not achieved with a lighter color. For example: A gray rock will reflect a warm color from the ground in it's shadow.
Composition: 1) The more complicated the scene you are painting, the simpler the rendering should be. 2) Start out by painting a smaller scene. Don't try to take on too much. 3) Decide on a focal point and maintain that focus by painting the rest of the scene with softer edges. 4) Vary you shapes. If there are five rocks make sure that they are all different shapes. The same goes for a row of trees. Make each distinctive.
Texture: 1) The heaviest texture should be used in the foreground because it jumps that area closer.
As I list these comments, they seem obvious but it is amazing how many of the paintings needed improvement on one or more of these basic points. I know many of my paintings do. Maybe I need to make up a checklist that I review before I consider a painting to be finished. Hey, that sounds like a great idea.
I didn't submit any pieces but I knew I would still learn from the panels comments. Here are a few of their suggestions regarding value, composition, and texture.
Value: 1) Make sure your light source is constant so the highlights and shadows confirm the light direction. 2) Try squinting. This will simplify what you are looking at and reduce it to very easily seen shapes of light and dark. 3) Reflective light is a change in temperature not achieved with a lighter color. For example: A gray rock will reflect a warm color from the ground in it's shadow.
Composition: 1) The more complicated the scene you are painting, the simpler the rendering should be. 2) Start out by painting a smaller scene. Don't try to take on too much. 3) Decide on a focal point and maintain that focus by painting the rest of the scene with softer edges. 4) Vary you shapes. If there are five rocks make sure that they are all different shapes. The same goes for a row of trees. Make each distinctive.
Texture: 1) The heaviest texture should be used in the foreground because it jumps that area closer.
As I list these comments, they seem obvious but it is amazing how many of the paintings needed improvement on one or more of these basic points. I know many of my paintings do. Maybe I need to make up a checklist that I review before I consider a painting to be finished. Hey, that sounds like a great idea.

1 Response to California Art Club Critique Session: The Making of Great Art
Leave a Comment