Reflections of an Artist

Learning from a Group Critique

Morning Light Through the Trees
Morning Light Through the Trees

Morning Light Through the Trees 6x12 Oil on Panel

      A group of artists gather together to paint on location. It happens all over and you probably have a group in your town. Every Thursday, I know I can join a supportive, talented and generous group of painters in the beautiful area around Pasadena, California. I have painted off and on with the San Gabriel group called "Thursdays En Plein Air" for a few years but haven't been out lately so this last week I met up with the troupe at Cobb Estate in the San Gabriel Mountains of Altadena.

      The early morning light was creating lovely shadows and soft pastel colors suffused the surrounding mountains. I painted with about 25 other artists and afterward there was a critique. If you have never had the benefit of listening to a critique from an artist you admire, you are missing out on a great learning experience. It takes a certain amount of humor combined with honesty to deliver both the positive and the negative sides to each painting. If done with equal amounts everyone leaves feeling inspired to push forward and come back for more. Although each artist is at a different stage of development in their craft, everyone is eager to improve. I always leave with positive feedback.

     This group is very successful and attracts dozens of artists every time they meet largely due to the wonderful people who contribute their time to make every outing worthwhile. I am impressed with the selfless dedication of everyone involved. You may not have a large group like this but every group will have different benefits. Try the critique too. If you are a small group critique each others work. If you paint with a larger group take turns each week. Every opinion is worthwhile but it is your choice as to which opinion you follow. Very early in my career I was naïve enough to believe that I knew it all. The real problem was that I didn't know enough to realize how little I knew.  It wasn't until I started to grow that I came to understand the nature of art. There is always something to learn. Don't settle for the next level. Push through to ascend even farther on your artists path.

Related Posts


Comments

2 Responses to Learning from a Group Critique

How nice that you have such an active group to paint with and that they do critiques. My local group rarely has that many people participating and many of them do not like critiques. Sometimes we will have a "show and tell" instead so people do not feel as intimidated, but I wish they were actual critiques. It takes an open mind and a thick skin to participate in critique sessions, but they are oh so valuable.

BTW, nice painting!

Yes Lee, the group is wonderful. Last night I went to a demo and the artist who paints with the Thursday group did the demo. He was very candid about how not to take yourself too seriously. He is very talented but kept saying how his paintings are all practice and that only one in five is really any good. His basic message was to stop agonizing over your work and enjoy it. Sage advise but not easy to follow. When giving a critique remember to start with the good things about the work and only then make suggestions regarding problems. Thank you Lee.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post