Reflections of an Artist

Panels Verses Canvas

Whitewater (Original Above)
Whitewater (Original Above)

Below is Cropped Image of Whitewater

 

      The spot where I painted Along the Kern River held a surprise. Looking north only a few feet from my spot was a cascade of rushing whitewater rapids. Other artists painted the rapids while I chose the calm beach but I knew I wanted to try the frothy brew at a later date. My chance came when my friend Marian Fortunati posted a photo of the rapids on Facebook and several artists asked if they could use it for a painting so I joined the group and painted Whitewater.

       I originally thought to paint the scene on a 12x12 panel but now that I can step back from the subject I am considering cropping the painting like the second image. After all the water is the important element and the sky and hills my be distracting. What do you think?

      One of the many good features about painting on panels is how easy it is to make these adjustments. The panels are glued onto the board so changing the size is only a matter of waiting until it is dry and then cutting the panel.

      If you don't use panels I recommend that you try panels for your smaller paintings.  Advantages include:

  • Take up a lot less room that canvas: Besides the convenience when carrying them into the field, I can stack a few dozen in a storage box to take with me in the trunk of my car. You never know when a chance meeting could result in a sale. I have sold several painting from my trunk.
  • Light weight: When you are carrying all your supplies to paint plein air, the weight of every item is a factor.
  • Indestructible: Depending on the backing most panels will hold up to rain, snow, extreme heat and cold without stretching, sagging or being punctured by a palette knife.
  • Sunlight Doesn't Show Through: Canvas allows light to shine through it. This is usually not a problem in the studio but outside it can be a disaster. The light shining through will distort the colors on the canvas so values and hue become impossible to see accurately.
  • Size adjustable: I have cut several panels after analysing the composition of the painting later. It is true that this can be done with a stretched canvas but it is a lot more of a hassle taking the canvas off the stretcher bars cutting it and then restretching it onto a different size.

      Panels are not appropriate for large paintings but for anything 16x20 or smaller think of using this canvas alternative.

Related Posts


Comments

8 Responses to Panels Verses Canvas

Sharon, I like your cropped version of the water rapids. Panels are my preferred surface for small paintings too.

Thanks Lee. I do too but someone else told me they like the original. I hope I get a few more comments before I decide.

I'm not going to be your deciding vote. I like them both. I have to say that when I saw the little thumbnail of the original on the FASO blog, I when OMG!!! It was gorgeous. I love the light on the hills as they come down toward the river in the farground.

However I do like the look of the cropped painting too.

You are an amazing painter. Have you posted the painting on FB yet or are you waiting to decide whether to crop it?

Hope to see you tomorrow. Miss talking with you.

Well Marian you are not help. I am still undecided but no problem since it has to dry before I cut anyway. I haven't posted it yet and thought I would on Monday. Thank you and see you at the CAC Iconic California reception. We will miss you today at the VAG luncheon.

I prefer the larger, uncropped painting.
Also, where did you come up with all those thoughts on the benefits of panels? Very impressive, and I'm sure helpful to other artists. Good job.

Sharon, I like the original. I like the context
of the whitewater. The cropped image could be
anywhere, usa. The distant mountains and mid ground
tell a story. best

Sharon, Since some people like the full version and some like the cropped version, maybe you should not crop the original, but do another painting with the cropped composition. Both are good. It seems to me one is about where the water is, and one is about the water itself.

Hi Carolyn. Thank you for your insight. You make an interesting point. Lee, as you say, this one does not seem to be an obvious choice. I want to paint a close up of the rapids too so I think that is the solution. Thanks everyone for you input. It was very helpful.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post